Skip to main content
web60

Web60 Features

Who Owns AI Website Content? What Irish Copyright Law Actually Says

Eamon Rheinisch··16 min read
A cream page held in a curved teal hand shape with a small navy star shape beside it, on a pale grey background

Everyone says the words an AI writes for you belong to nobody. Describe your business to a chatbot or an AI website builder, get a homepage back, and according to the pub version of copyright law, that text is fair game. Anyone can take it. You cannot complain.

It is one of the questions that comes up on sales calls far more often than you would expect, usually as a quiet worry near the end: if the AI wrote my website, is it actually mine? The honest answer is more interesting than the myth, and a lot more useful. Ireland, as it happens, has a rule for exactly this. Whether that rule would survive a courtroom is a separate question.

Consider a composite case, built from the kind of situation we hear versions of. A mobile bicycle repair service in Sligo builds its website with an AI tool over a quiet weekend. The service pages come out well: clear, friendly, and after a bit of editing they even sound like the owner. Then, just as the spring rush starts, a new competitor launches with a services page that reads almost line for line like theirs. The structure matches, the joke about punctures is there, and the call-out area is described in near-identical words. The owner's first thought is not how to stop it. It is whether they are even allowed to complain.

That hesitation rests on five myths. Each one is worth taking apart, because the answers decide what you should keep on file, what you should never paste into a chatbot, and where your website should live. If you are newer to the idea of AI building a site at all, start with what AI-powered WordPress actually means for a business owner. This piece is about what happens after the site exists.

Myth 1: Nobody Owns Words an AI Wrote

Ireland is unusual here. The Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 had a category for this long before anyone had heard of ChatGPT.

Section 2 of the Act defines a computer-generated work as one "generated by computer in circumstances where the author of the work is not an individual" [1]. Section 21(f), as published in the Law Reform Commission's revised version of the Act, then names the author of that kind of work: "the person by whom the arrangements necessary for the creation of the work are undertaken".

And the protection is not a token one. Under section 30, copyright in a computer-generated work expires 70 years after the date it is "first lawfully made available to the public" [2]. The clock starts the day your page is deployed to production.

So what does that mean for the bike mechanic in Sligo? It means the starting position under Irish law is not "nobody owns this". Somebody does. The strongest candidate is whoever made the arrangements: the person who chose the tool, wrote the description, decided what to keep and published it. For most small business websites, that is the owner.

The word doing the heavy lifting

Strongest candidate is not the same as certain. I have not found an Irish court decision applying section 21(f) to a modern AI tool, and a lawyer on the other side could argue that the company behind the AI made the real arrangements. Nobody knows how that argument would land yet.

If a copying dispute ever matters to your business commercially, that is a conversation for a solicitor. What the Act gives you is a reason to take your own website seriously as something you can defend, rather than shrugging it off as machine output nobody owns.

Myth 2: The Law Is Settled, So It Is Safely Yours Forever

This is where the myth flips. Some owners hear about section 21(f) and conclude the matter is closed. It is not.

The Irish rule sits awkwardly beside the way European copyright usually works, which is built around human creativity. Our own Act uses the phrase "the author's own intellectual creation" when it defines a computer program [1]. A work with no individual author is hard to square with that test, and the Court of Justice has not yet said how the two fit together.

Look at our nearest neighbour for a sense of where things are heading. The UK has an almost identical rule in its 1988 Act. In its Report on Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, published on 18 March 2026 after more than 11,000 consultation responses, the UK government said that "in the absence of evidence of its ongoing value, we propose that this specific type of protection should be removed", while copyright "should continue to protect works created with AI assistance" [4]. A proposal, not yet law. Still, it tells you which way the wind is blowing.

The United States never had a rule like ours. The US Copyright Office concluded in January 2025 that AI output is protected only where a human has determined sufficient expressive elements, which can include "creative arrangements or modifications of the output, but not the mere provision of prompts" [3].

The pattern across all three

Put those together and a clear picture emerges. Protection for pure machine output is the shakiest ground in every system. Protection for what a human shaped, chose, rewrote and added is the firmest, everywhere.

In practice, the most defensible version of your website is the one you have actually edited. Not a quick pass for typos. A proper rewrite of the parts that matter: how you started, how you work, what you do differently from the other three businesses in your trade. That happens to be exactly what customers respond to as well, which is why I keep coming back to the difference between AI that builds your site and AI that writes your words.

The alternative is uncomfortable. A homepage published exactly as the AI produced it is the version you would have the hardest time defending, and the version a dozen competitors could have produced themselves with a similar description.

A cream page covered in flowing teal brush strokes, laid over two navy-edged teal pages on a warm grey background
The most defensible version of an AI draft is the one you have rewritten in your own voice.

Myth 3: If It Is Yours, Competitors Cannot Copy Any of It

Now the opposite mistake. Owning the copyright in your words does not give you a monopoly on your business information.

Copyright protects expression, not facts. A recent opinion from the Court of Justice puts this unusually clearly. On 3 November 2026, Advocate General Szpunar delivered his opinion in Case C-250/25, a dispute between a Hungarian publisher and Google over the Gemini chatbot. According to the Court's press release, he stressed that the publisher's right "does not protect the mere facts reported in press publications", only "the specific form of expression of those publications" [5].

Two caveats. That case concerns a special right for news publishers, not ordinary business websites, and an Advocate General's opinion is not binding; the judges are still deliberating. But the distinction between facts and expression runs right through copyright generally, and it maps neatly onto the Sligo example.

What a competitor can and cannot take

The competitor is entitled to list puncture repairs and brake servicing, charge similar prices and cover the same towns. None of that belongs to anyone. What they are not entitled to do is lift your sentences, your page structure and your turns of phrase wholesale, especially the parts you wrote yourself.

If it happens to you, the sensible order of events is:

  • Save dated copies of both pages. Screenshots with the date visible, plus the web addresses. Pages change quickly once someone knows they have been noticed.
  • Ask first, politely and specifically. A short message pointing to the copied passages resolves more of these than any legal letter. Sometimes the copying turns out to be a freelancer's shortcut the other owner never knew about.
  • Escalate only if it matters. Most reputable hosting providers have a process for copyright complaints, and a solicitor's letter is the next step if the copying is costing you work.

Myth 4: AI Text Is Original, So It Cannot Get You Into Trouble

This one bites owners who think they are being clever. The trick goes like this: find a competitor's page you admire, paste it into a chatbot, and ask it to "reword this so it is different". Out comes something that looks new.

It may not be new enough. In the same opinion, the Advocate General's test for infringement in the chatbot context was whether the answer merely reports facts or instead "reuses the form of expression of that publication in a recognisable manner" [5]. A lightly reworded copy of someone else's page is exactly what that kind of test is aimed at. And the AI does not publish it. You do, under your business name.

Think about how that goes wrong. The awkward email does not come from the AI company. It comes from the business whose page you fed in, it lands in your inbox, and it quotes your own homepage back at you.

Feed it facts, not pages

The fix is simple and it produces better websites. Give the AI your own raw material: the services you actually offer, the areas you cover, how you got started, the questions customers ask you on the phone. Let it organise and draft from that. Then rewrite the result in your own voice.

You end up with text that is plainly yours, that is not a near-copy of anyone, and that answers the questions your customers really have. Three wins from one habit.

Myth 5: Whoever Hosts Your Website Owns It

The last myth confuses two different things: copyright and control. You can own every word on your website on paper and still be unable to take it anywhere.

On closed website builders such as Wix or Squarespace, the words you type in may well remain yours under the platform's terms. But the design, the template and the way your pages fit together live inside that platform's system. If prices go up or the platform changes direction, leaving usually means rebuilding. Ownership on paper is worth very little if the only working copy of your website lives somewhere you cannot leave without starting again.

WordPress works differently. The built-in export tool, under Tools then Export, creates a standard file containing your posts, pages, comments, categories, tags and other content, which another WordPress site can import. That openness is one reason the platform runs a little under four in ten of all websites, and well over half of the sites whose content management system can be identified, according to W3Techs' figures this week [6].

What a sensible home for an AI-built site looks like

Before choosing where your site lives, it is worth setting a standard. A sensible home for a website built with AI should give you:

  1. Your words in an open format. Stored somewhere you can export from at any time, without asking anyone's permission or paying a release fee.
  2. A first draft that starts from you. A builder that works from your own description of your business, so the raw material is your facts rather than someone else's page.
  3. Backups you can restore yourself. So a bad edit, a broken plugin or a hacked account does not wipe out the version of your site you might one day need to show someone.
  4. A price that stays put. So you are never too invested to leave and too annoyed to stay.

That is the standard we built Web60 around. You describe your business and Web60's AI builder turns that description into a full WordPress site in under a minute, so the starting point is your own account of what you do. It is full WordPress with the entire plugin and theme ecosystem, not a walled garden, which means the standard export tools work on your site like any other. Nightly backups with one-click restore run automatically, safety snapshots are taken before updates, and a one-click staging environment lets you verify big edits before you deploy them to production. Everything is included for €60 a year, with no upsells, and the data stays in Ireland.

What no host can do

One honest limitation, and it applies to us as much as anyone. No hosting provider can give you copyright. That comes from the law and from what you write, not from where the site lives. An export file or a backup proves you had certain words on your site on a certain date. It does not prove you wrote them, and it does not settle the section 21(f) question either.

And to be fair to the other end of the market: if you are a large brand producing thousands of AI-written product pages with a legal department that wants contractual cover if the output ever infringes someone, the enterprise AI platforms that sell copyright indemnities as part of their contracts genuinely suit that workload better. That cover costs serious money and comes with serious paperwork. It is not what a three-person business needs, and it is not what most businesses reading this are.

Cream pages lifting out of an open teal box towards an open navy doorway on a light grey background
Copyright is one question. Being able to take your website with you is another.

The Paper Trail That Makes an AI-Built Website Yours

None of this needs a solicitor on retainer. It needs a folder, and about ten minutes the next time you sit down with your site. Keep:

  • Your original description and notes. Save whatever you gave the AI builder, with the date. It is the clearest record of the arrangements you made, which is precisely what section 21(f) asks about.
  • The date you first deployed. The 70-year clock under section 30 starts when the work is first lawfully made available, so it is worth knowing when that was.
  • Your edits. WordPress keeps a revision each time you save an update to a page or post, covering the title and content by default. Those revisions are a running record of the human work you added on top of the draft. Do not clear them out to tidy up.
  • Your own material. Photos you took, your price list, the brochure you designed years ago. These are plainly human-authored and plainly yours, and they make your site harder to confuse with anyone else's.
  • Permission for anything you did not write. Supplier product descriptions, testimonials and stock images all need their own clearance, AI or no AI.

Where That Leaves Your Website

The myth says nobody owns what an AI writes. Irish law says somebody probably does, and that the somebody is most likely you. Our nearest neighbour is moving away from that position, and the courts have not tested it, which is exactly why the parts of your site you shape yourself matter most.

You do not need to become a copyright expert to run a website built with AI. Three habits cover almost everything: put your own facts in, put your own voice on top, and keep your site somewhere you can export it from. With those in place, the bike mechanic in our example could have sent that polite message with confidence instead of hesitating.

Next time you open your homepage, read it out loud and ask yourself whether it sounds like you.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I copyright a website written by AI in Ireland?

Possibly, and more strongly than in many countries. The Copyright and Related Rights Act 2000 treats a work generated by computer with no individual author as a computer-generated work, and names its author as the person who made the arrangements necessary for its creation. Copyright in it lasts 70 years from when it is first lawfully made available to the public. No Irish court appears to have applied that rule to a modern AI tool yet, so the safest position is to rewrite and add to the AI draft yourself, because the parts you shape are protected on ordinary copyright principles.

Does the AI company own the content it writes for me?

Usually not in practice. Many AI tools say in their terms that the output is yours to use, but terms differ between tools and change over time, so read the terms of the specific tool you used. Under Irish law the author of a computer-generated work is whoever made the arrangements needed to create it, which for a small business website is most plausibly the owner who chose the tool, wrote the description and published the result.

Can a competitor copy my AI-generated website text?

A competitor can always use the same facts: the services you offer, the areas you cover, similar prices and opening hours. Copyright protects the form of expression, not facts. Copying your actual sentences and page structure wholesale is a different matter, and your position is strongest where you rewrote or added to the AI draft. Save dated copies of both pages, ask the other business to remove the copied text, and speak to a solicitor if it matters commercially.

Is it legal to use AI to rewrite a competitor's website?

It is risky. Feeding someone else's page into a chatbot and asking it to reword the text can produce output that still reuses the original's expression in a recognisable way, and you are the one who publishes it. Give the AI your own facts and notes instead: what you do, where you work, how you started and what customers ask you. The result is safer and reads more like your business.

If I leave my website builder, can I take my AI-written content with me?

It depends on the platform. On a closed builder the words may be yours under the terms, but the design and the way the pages fit together live inside that platform, so moving usually means rebuilding. On WordPress, the built-in export tool under Tools, then Export creates a file of your posts, pages, comments, categories, tags and other content that another WordPress site can import, so your content is not tied to one company.

Sources

Eamon Rheinisch
Eamon RheinischSales Director, Web60

Eamon leads sales at Web60 and SmartHost, working directly with Irish business owners making the switch from cheap shared hosting to managed WordPress. With a background in enterprise technology sales — including Oracle and multiple Irish SaaS businesses — he understands the questions Irish SMEs ask before committing to a hosting platform. He writes about hosting comparisons, total cost of ownership, web design for Irish businesses, and how to evaluate what you’re actually buying.

More by Eamon Rheinisch →

Ready to get your business online?

Describe your business. AI builds your website in 60 seconds.

Build My Website Free →
Buy NowTry Free
Who Owns AI Website Content? Irish Copyright Law | Web60