Skip to main content
web60

Comparisons

Patreon Alternative for Small Businesses: Paid Memberships on Your Own Website

Eamon Rheinisch··15 min read
Flat illustration of a navy cylinder with a narrow teal doorway on the left and a teal circle linked to a ring of navy dots on the right, split across olive and off-white backgrounds

On 1 November, Patreon finished moving its last creators on older billing models over to subscription billing, because Apple would not let the iPhone app carry on any other way [1]. Only a small slice of creators were affected, around 4% by Patreon's own count, but the episode put a question on the table that I am now hearing from people who would never call themselves creators.

If you sell ongoing access to something, where should your paying members live?

I mean the yoga teacher with a library of recorded classes. The cookery school running a monthly recipe club. The craft tutor whose students pay a few euro a month for new patterns and a live Q&A. Small, steady, recurring income, the kind that keeps a sole trader's January from being frightening. For years the easy answer was Patreon, and for some people it still is. For a growing number of the owner-operators I talk to, it has quietly become the expensive one.

The Choice at a Glance

Before the detail, the whole comparison in five lines. Every row gets its own section below, because each one hides a decision.

What you are comparingPatreonMembers' area on your own website
Platform fee10% of income for pages launched after 4 August 2025None; you pay for hosting instead
Card processingCharged on top, with currency conversion and payout feesStripe in Ireland: 1.5% + €0.25 on a standard European card
Sign-ups inside the iPhone appApple commission of up to 30%No app store between you and the member
Tax collectionPatreon handles most of it for youYour job, with your accountant
Moving members laterThe email list exports, paid subscriptions do notYou hold both

What Each Euro Pays For

The platform fee

Patreon's own pricing page sets its cut at 10% of the income you earn there, plus payment processing, currency conversion and payout fees, and applicable taxes. That 10% is the standard plan for anyone who published a page after 4 August 2025. Older pages kept their legacy plans, so a long-standing creator may be paying less. One catch in Patreon's help centre is easy to miss: if a legacy page is unpublished, by you or by Patreon, it moves to the 10% plan when it comes back.

Ten percent sounds modest. Annualise it.

Take an illustrative members' club of 40 people paying €10 a month. That is €4,800 a year coming in, and before a single card is processed, €480 of it goes on the platform fee. For a club small enough that you know every member by name, that is eight years of Web60 hosting leaving the business every twelve months.

Card processing

Moving to your own website does not make payment fees disappear. You still need a payment provider, and Stripe is one that WordPress membership plugins commonly connect to. Its published Irish pricing is 1.5% + €0.25 for a standard European card, 2.5% + €0.25 for a UK card and 3.15% + €0.25 for international cards, with an extra 2% where currency conversion is needed [4]. If your plugin runs on Stripe's own subscription engine, Stripe Billing, add 0.7% of billing volume on the pay-as-you-go plan.

Run the same illustrative club through those numbers. A €10 payment on an Irish debit card costs 40 cent. Across 40 members for a year, card fees land somewhere between €190 and €230 if most of them pay with Irish or other European cards, depending on whether Billing applies. Add €60 for hosting and the whole own-site bill sits in the region of €250 to €290, before any plugin licence.

Patreon's equivalent is €480 before its own processing charges, which sit on top. So at this size the gap is a few hundred euro a year, and it widens with every member you add. I would still rather you open your own payout statement than take my arithmetic as gospel. Your card mix is not my card mix. What does a few hundred euro mean in practice? For a small studio it is a new set of mats, or a month's rent on the room. It is real money, and it leaves every year without anyone noticing, because a percentage never arrives as a bill.

Flat illustration of a wide teal stream narrowing into thin channels that drain into a small navy pool, on an off-white and sand background
A percentage fee never arrives as a bill, which is exactly why it is so easy to ignore.

The iPhone Sign-Up Problem

This is the part the November deadline actually changed, and it is the one that catches owners off guard.

When someone joins a membership inside Patreon's iPhone or iPad app, they pay through Apple's in-app purchase system. Apple takes 30% of those payments, dropping to 15% once a subscription has run for more than a year, as MacRumors reported when the deadline was announced [2]. Patreon's help centre gives creators two options: raise prices inside the iOS app to cover the fee, which is the default, or keep one price everywhere and absorb it. Members can avoid Apple's cut by joining through the web browser on their phone rather than the app [1]. Most people, though, tap the button in front of them.

What that looks like for a teaching business

Consider a composite case, built from the kind of call I take most weeks: a fiddle teacher in Donegal with a members' library of weekly tune lessons and students spread from the Rosses to Boston. A good share of them are older learners using the app on an iPad a grandchild set up. Either those learners pay noticeably more than the person who joined on a laptop, or the teacher quietly gives up close to a third of their first year's fees.

Neither option was the teacher's idea.

A members' area on your own website has no app store in the middle. The member opens your site in whatever browser they use, pays one price through your payment provider, and logs in. Same price on an iPad as on a laptop. That is not a technical nicety. It is the difference between a pricing decision you made and one that was made for you.

Rules You Did Not Write

None of this is really a criticism of Patreon. When Apple reinstated the requirement in January, Patreon said creators on legacy billing would "now have to endure the whiplash of another policy reversal", the third such change from Apple in 18 months [3]. The platform is squeezed too.

And that is the point. On a rented platform, two layers of policy sit above your business: the platform's and the app store's. Either one can change your prices, your billing schedule or your fees, and you find out by email.

Some of those emails carry real consequences. Patreon's own FAQ explained that creators who charged per creation would have their billing paused after the switch, until they logged in and reviewed their new monthly prices. A paused billing run is a month of income that simply does not arrive, noticed by someone who was busy teaching a class when it happened.

Who Owns the Relationship

Let me be fair here, because this is where comparisons often get lazy. Patreon does let you export your member list as a spreadsheet, email addresses included, from its relationship manager. You are not locked out of your own audience's contact details.

The payments stay behind

What you cannot export is the payment. Even the migration guides written by other membership platforms say plainly that there is no direct way to move paid subscriptions off Patreon. Every paying member has to sign up again somewhere new and re-enter their card details.

That is the real switching cost, and it is a people cost rather than a technical one. Ask a hundred members to do something fiddly on a weeknight and some of them will not get round to it. Each one who drifts away takes a monthly payment with them.

On your own website, the subscriptions sit in a payment account in your business's name, attached to a site you control. Redesign the site or change host later, and the members and their payment arrangements are still in accounts you own.

Flat illustration of rounded navy shapes moving along a teal path from a dark frame towards an open teal doorway, on an off-white background
The member list can travel. The payments have to be rebuilt, one sign-up at a time.

Where Patreon Genuinely Wins

I would not be doing my job if I told everyone to leave. There are cases where Patreon is the better fit, and the biggest one is tax.

Patreon's pricing page says it takes care of most applicable tax collection and remittance for creators. That is worth more than it sounds. Sell recorded content from your own site to members in other EU countries and the VAT position becomes yours to manage. Revenue's guidance on electronically supplied services is that, while those cross-border sales to consumers stay under €10,000 in the current and previous calendar year, they are subject to Irish VAT; go over it and VAT is due in each customer's country, either by registering there or through the One Stop Shop [5].

Live classes taught by a real person may not count as electronic services at all, which is precisely the sort of question your accountant should answer, not a blog post. The refund and VAT rules for downloads are covered in our guide to selling digital products from an Irish website.

When Patreon is the right call

The honest version, then. If you are testing whether anyone will pay at all, if most of your audience is scattered across a dozen countries, and if you have never filed a VAT return, Patreon's 10% is partly buying you an accounts department. That is a fair trade, and I would tell a prospect exactly that.

The limitation on your own side

The own-site route has a limitation of its own, and it is better named now than discovered after you switch. Hosting your members' area does not process payments. You still open a Stripe account and choose a membership plugin, and some of the better plugins charge a yearly licence. Budget for that before you compare totals.

What a Proper Members' Area Needs

Whatever you build it on, a members' area worth trusting with recurring income does six things well:

  • Gated content by level. A login, with each lesson, recipe or video visible only to the tiers that pay for it.
  • Recurring payments through a reputable provider. Cards charged on schedule, with a clear way for members to cancel.
  • Failed-payment handling. Automatic retries and an email to the member when a card expires, so you are not chasing people one by one.
  • A member list you can export. Your audience, in a format you can take anywhere.
  • Nightly backups. Member accounts are data you cannot recreate from memory.
  • Safe updates. Plugin and theme updates tested before they reach production.

The payment side, from card renewals to retry rules, is covered in our piece on recurring payments on your own website.

Where the hosting comes in

A good hosting platform takes care of the last two and leaves you free to choose the rest. Web60 does that. You get full WordPress, which runs nearly four in ten websites according to W3Techs [6], so you can install whichever membership plugin suits your business. Describe your business to the AI builder and you have a working site in under a minute, then add the members' area yourself. No agency, and nobody billing you by the hour every time you add a new class.

Underneath, nightly backups with one-click restore and automatic safety snapshots before updates mean a membership plugin update that breaks logins can be rolled back rather than rebuilt. Without that, a broken update in the week a new term starts means members locked out of what they paid for and an inbox full of people asking why. The one-click staging environment lets you test the update on a copy first, so production never sees it until you have verified it works. Member logins and emails sit on SmartHost's sovereign Irish cloud, so your members' data stays in Ireland.

All of it comes as part of Web60's €60-a-year all-inclusive hosting, with SSL, security and support from a real Irish team included.

Moving Members Without Losing Them

If the numbers point towards your own site, four steps keep the move calm:

  1. Deploy the members' area first. Build it, then verify a full join, renewal and cancellation with your own card before anyone else sees it.
  2. Export and explain. Download your member list and write to members personally, saying why you are moving and what it means for their price.
  3. Run both for one billing cycle. Close new sign-ups on Patreon but leave existing tiers live while people move across, ideally with a founding-member price as a thank-you.
  4. Close the old tiers. Once the stragglers have had a fair chance and a reminder, switch off the Patreon tiers so nobody pays twice.

The step that matters most is the second. Members follow a person, not a platform, and a straight explanation from you will move more of them than any discount.

Where Your Members Should Live

Not everyone should leave Patreon. If you are still finding out whether a membership works, or most of your members are overseas and you have no appetite for VAT returns, it does a real job for its 10%.

If you run a settled club with mostly Irish and European members and steady monthly income, though, the sums have shifted. A platform fee, a possible Apple commission on every iPhone sign-up, and rules that can change by email add up to a high price for renting the room your best customers sit in. A members' area on your own WordPress site costs less to run, charges everyone the same, and keeps the relationship in your name.

Pull up last year's payout statements, total what went on fees, and look at where your members actually live. Set that figure against the cost of running it yourself, and you will know where the next year of your membership belongs.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Patreon take from creators in 2026?

For pages published after 4 August 2025, Patreon's standard platform fee is 10% of the income you earn there. Payment processing, currency conversion and payout fees are charged on top, along with applicable taxes. Members who join inside the iPhone app also trigger Apple's App Store commission.

Can I move my Patreon members to my own website?

You can move the people, but not their payments. Patreon lets you export your member list, including email addresses, as a spreadsheet. Paid subscriptions cannot be transferred, so every member has to sign up again on your website and enter their card details.

Do I have to charge VAT on memberships sold from my own website in Ireland?

It depends on what you sell, who buys it and your own VAT status. According to Revenue, cross-border sales of electronically supplied services to consumers in other EU countries are subject to Irish VAT while they total less than 10,000 euro in the current and previous calendar year. Above that, VAT is due in each customer's country, through local registration or the One Stop Shop. Live classes may be treated differently from recorded content, so ask your accountant before you launch.

Why do Patreon memberships cost more on iPhone?

Members who join inside Patreon's iOS app pay through Apple's in-app purchase system, and Apple takes up to 30% of those payments, falling to 15% once a subscription has run for more than a year. Patreon lets creators raise iOS prices to cover the fee, which is the default, or absorb it. Joining through a web browser on the phone avoids Apple's commission.

Do I need technical skills to run a members' area on WordPress?

Not deep ones. An AI website builder can deploy a WordPress site in under a minute. From there you add a membership plugin from the dashboard, connect a payment provider such as Stripe, and choose which pages each membership level can see. Try plugin updates in a staging environment before they reach production.

Sources

Eamon Rheinisch
Eamon RheinischSales Director, Web60

Eamon leads sales at Web60 and SmartHost, working directly with Irish business owners making the switch from cheap shared hosting to managed WordPress. With a background in enterprise technology sales — including Oracle and multiple Irish SaaS businesses — he understands the questions Irish SMEs ask before committing to a hosting platform. He writes about hosting comparisons, total cost of ownership, web design for Irish businesses, and how to evaluate what you’re actually buying.

More by Eamon Rheinisch →

Ready to get your business online?

Describe your business. AI builds your website in 60 seconds.

Build My Website Free →
Buy NowTry Free
Patreon Alternative: Paid Members on Your Own Site | Web60