Comparisons
Therapy Directory Profile vs Your Own Website: A Letter to Counsellors in Private Practice

If you work as a counsellor or psychotherapist in private practice, you almost certainly have a directory profile. You set it up in your first month, picked the photo that looked approachable without looking like a dating app, wrote a few hundred words about how you work, and ticked the boxes for anxiety, grief and relationships. Then the free months ended, the card started being charged, and the profile became one of those things that just runs in the background.
This letter is about that profile, and about the website you may or may not have alongside it. I am not going to tell you to cancel anything. I sell websites for a living, so weigh my view with that in mind. But most of my week goes on conversations with sole traders weighing up exactly this kind of decision, and the honest answer is rarely one or the other.
By the end, you should have a clear picture of three things: what each option does for your practice, what each one costs you, and which of them you actually own.
What Your Monthly Fee Is Buying
Start with the number. Psychology Today, one of the best-known therapist directories, currently charges €19.95 a month in Ireland once the six free months for new members run out, with no contract and the option to cancel at any time [1]. That works out at €239.40 a year.
Not a fortune. If one new client a year finds you through it, the listing has paid for itself. I sell websites, and I still would not argue with that.
For that money you get a profile on a site that people looking for help already know to search. You appear in the listings for your area and for the issues you work with. People can ring you or send a message straight from the page. For somebody starting out, that is a real service.
You also get neighbours. Lots of them. When I checked today, the directory's Dublin 1 counselling page alone showed 154 counsellors [2]. That figure will have moved by the time you read this, and not every one of those people is chasing the same clients as you, but the pattern repeats wherever a directory page gets busy. Your profile is not a shop window. It is one tile in a wall of near-identical tiles, each with a headshot, a credential line and a few sentences, laid out in an order you did not choose.
You Do Not Choose Where You Appear
Think about how someone actually uses that wall. They have had a bad week, possibly a bad year. After the house goes quiet, they finally sit down with their phone and search. They read the first handful of profiles, message two people whose faces felt kind, and put the phone down. Most will never reach the fourth page.
If that is where your profile sits that night, the enquiry never existed as far as your practice is concerned. Nobody turned you down. You were simply never seen.
Your position on the list is decided by the directory. Last December, the US health-costs outlet ClearHealthCosts reported that some American therapists felt their directory referrals had fallen off over the previous year or so despite paying the same fee, with a few describing profiles that slipped from the first page to much later ones [3]. That evidence was largely anecdotal. Psychology Today disputed any system-wide decline and told the reporter that total contacts to therapists had held up, and the Irish picture may look quite different again.
One line in the company's response is worth holding on to, though. It said it periodically updates its algorithms. Nobody is doing anything sinister there; every platform tunes its rankings. What it does mean is that your visibility to new clients is a setting on somebody else's computer, and it can change without a word to you.
A composite case
Consider a scenario built from common patterns rather than any one person: a psychotherapist in Kerry, three years in practice, whose enquiries thin out over a winter. Nothing on the profile has changed. Newer profiles with fresher photos now sit above it on the county page. With no website of their own, the directory is the only door into the practice, and there is no way to tell whether the dip is the season, the algorithm or something they did. A different headline cannot be tested on a page they do not control. How many people looked and moved on stays invisible. All that is left is to keep paying and hope.
When the payments stop
The no-contract terms cut both ways. You can walk away from the directory whenever you like [1], which is genuinely good. But the listing, its place in the results and any endorsements from colleagues belong to the platform. Stop paying and the listing comes down. What you keep is whatever you saved yourself: your words and your photo.
Sellers who build on online marketplaces hit the same wall, and we went through that pattern in full in our piece on renting a marketplace shop instead of owning your website. Details differ. The ownership problem is identical.
A Profile Has a Few Lines to Earn Trust
Your clients are not choosing a plumber. They are choosing a person to trust with the hardest parts of their life, and they are usually doing it anxiously. A directory profile gives you a fixed set of fields and a few hundred words to make that case.
A website of your own gives you room to answer the questions people are often too nervous to ask by email:
- How the first session works. What happens when they arrive, how long it lasts, and that they do not have to tell you everything at once.
- Fees and cancellations. Stated plainly, so nobody has to ask.
- Where you are. Which entrance, whether the room is on the ground floor, where to park, and whether online sessions are an option.
- Your training and accreditation. Who accredits you, what that involves and how your supervision works.
- Your approach, in your own voice. Not the directory's tick-boxes, but how you actually work with people.
That fourth point matters more in your profession than most. There is no open statutory register for counsellors and psychotherapists yet. CORU, the regulator, says those registers are not yet open and that it cannot give a definitive date for opening them [4]. Until they are, the person reading about you relies on what you tell them about your qualifications and your accrediting body. A website lets you explain that properly, in plain language, rather than compressing it into a line of letters after your name.
The business consequence is simple. Someone who has read your page on what to expect is more likely to arrive at the first session calmer and already half-sure they chose well. Someone who only saw a tile in a grid arrives with every one of those questions still in their head, if they book at all.

Where the First Message Lands
People do not write neutral enquiries to a therapist. The first message often says why they are getting in touch: the panic attacks, the bereavement, the marriage. That is data concerning health, and the Data Protection Commission lists it among the special categories of personal data whose processing is prohibited except in limited circumstances set out in Article 9 of the GDPR [5].
You cannot stop people telling you things in a first email, and you would not want to. What you can control is how many systems that message passes through before it reaches you, and what your contact form invites people to share.
When someone contacts you through a directory, that first message is typically handled by the directory's own contact system before it reaches your inbox, under the directory's privacy terms. On your own website, the form is yours, the privacy notice is yours, and you choose where the site is hosted. We have covered the detail of health questions on booking and contact forms separately, and it is worth reading before you build anything.
The limit of owning the form
Owning the website does not make you compliant on its own. A contact form on a well-run Irish server can still ask for far more than it needs. Keep yours to a name, a way to reach the person, and an optional message box with a gentle line saying they do not need to share details until you speak. Then run the wording past your accrediting body or a data protection adviser.
Hosting decides where the data lives. The form decides how much of it there is.
The Two Side by Side
| What you are comparing | Directory profile | Your own website |
|---|---|---|
| Yearly cost | €239.40 after six free months (€19.95 a month) | €60 a year on Web60, with hosting, SSL and backups included |
| Who decides your position | The directory's ranking algorithm | Google ranks the page, but every word on it is yours |
| Room to explain yourself | Fixed fields and a few hundred words | As many pages as your practice needs |
| Where first enquiries land | The directory's contact system, under its terms | Your own form and privacy notice, hosted in Ireland |
| When you stop paying | The listing comes down | Your content is yours to take elsewhere |
Each row has a fair counterpoint, which brings me to the part of this letter that might surprise you.
Where the Directory Earns Its Fee
If you qualified this year and have no reviews, no presence on Google and no referral network, the directory is very likely your fastest route to first enquiries. A directory that has been around for years has a head start in search that a brand-new website will take months to close. Keep it. That is a fair trade for €19.95 a month.
The same goes if you work entirely online with clients all over the country. A national directory casts a wider net than a new local site will in its first year.
So the honest recommendation is not website instead of directory. It is website underneath directory. Let the directory be one door into your practice, not the building:
- Deploy your own site first. Start with the five pages listed above and nothing more.
- Add your web address to the profile. Do it wherever the directory lets you include one.
- Point your Google Business Profile at your own site. People who search your name should land somewhere you control.
- Record how every new client found you. After six months you will know what the €239.40 is really doing.
Paying a middleman for introductions follows the same arithmetic wherever it shows up, from therapy to trades, and we set it out in detail in buying leads instead of owning your website.

Building Your Own Site Without Taking On a Second Job
You did not train for years to become a web designer, and you should not need to. A sensible website for a private practice meets a short list of standards:
- You can write and change every page yourself, without paying anyone by the hour.
- The site is served over HTTPS, so the browser never flags it as "Not secure" on the very page where someone is about to describe what they are going through.
- It is backed up every night, so a bad plugin update means a rollback rather than a rebuild.
- Visitor numbers are measured without a cookie banner standing between an anxious visitor and your contact page.
- The data sits in Ireland, with support from real people you can reach.
- The price is fixed and known in advance.
The old route to that was an agency: somewhere between €3,000 and €5,000 to build it, weeks spent briefing a stranger on how you work with clients, and €75 to €150 an hour every time you wanted to change a sentence. That model made sense when building a website needed specialist skills. It does not any more. Nobody can describe your practice better than you, and AI has removed the part that used to need a developer.
Web60 meets that list. You describe your practice to the AI builder and get a professionally designed WordPress site in under a minute, then edit it yourself from day one. WordPress runs nearly four in ten websites, according to W3Techs [6], so you are never locked into a closed system. Free SSL is provisioned and renewed automatically. Nightly backups with one-click restore, plus automatic safety snapshots before updates, mean a broken update gets rolled back instead of leaving your contact page down while enquiries go nowhere.
The built-in analytics are privacy-first and need no cookie consent for analytics tracking, though you should still describe them in your privacy notice. Everything runs on SmartHost's sovereign Irish cloud, so messages from your contact form stay in Ireland, and support comes from a team based here.
All of it sits inside Web60's €60-a-year all-inclusive hosting, roughly a quarter of what a year on the directory costs. If you have been meaning to get a site up alongside your profile, describing your practice to the builder takes less time than writing your directory bio did.
What I Would Do in Your Position
If the directory is bringing you clients, keep paying for it. Twenty euro a month is a small price for a door that opens.
Just do not let it be the only door. Put a website of your own underneath it, written in your voice and explaining how you work. Then send everything else to that address instead of the directory page: your Google profile, your email signature, the card you leave with GPs and pharmacies.
Ask each new client how they found you. In six months you will have your own numbers rather than a platform's, and you will know exactly what each door is worth to your practice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Psychology Today worth it for therapists in Ireland?
For many therapists it can be, especially in the first year of private practice. In Ireland the listing costs €19.95 a month after six free months, so one new client a year usually covers it. The limits are that the directory decides where your profile appears and the listing comes down when you stop paying. The safest set-up is a directory profile plus your own website, with the profile pointing people to your site wherever the directory allows.
How much does a Psychology Today listing cost in Ireland?
Psychology Today's Irish sign-up page lists €19.95 a month after six free months for new members, with no contract and the option to cancel at any time. Over a full year that comes to €239.40. Check the sign-up page for current terms before you join, as prices can change.
Do counsellors and psychotherapists in Ireland need a website?
It is not a legal requirement, but it is the only online presence you fully control. A website lets you explain your approach, fees, location, accessibility and accreditation in your own words, and gives your Google Business Profile somewhere to point. A directory profile is useful, but its layout, its ranking and its continued existence depend on the platform.
Is a contact form on a therapist's website covered by GDPR?
Yes. Any form that collects names and contact details processes personal data, and enquiries to a therapist often include health information, which the Data Protection Commission lists as a special category of personal data with stricter rules. Keep the form short, make the message box optional, explain in your privacy notice how enquiries are handled, and check the wording with your accrediting body or a data protection adviser.
Is there a statutory register for counsellors and psychotherapists in Ireland?
Not yet. CORU is establishing statutory registration for counsellors and psychotherapists, but it says the registers are not yet open and it cannot give a definitive date for opening them. Until they open, clients rely on what you tell them about your training and accrediting body, which is one more reason to explain it clearly on your own website.
Should my Google Business Profile link to my directory profile or my own website?
Your own website, if you have one. It is the page you control, it explains your practice in full, and it does not disappear if you change or leave a directory. Keep the directory profile as an extra route in, and link it to your site wherever the directory lets you add a website address.
Sources
Eamon leads sales at Web60 and SmartHost, working directly with Irish business owners making the switch from cheap shared hosting to managed WordPress. With a background in enterprise technology sales — including Oracle and multiple Irish SaaS businesses — he understands the questions Irish SMEs ask before committing to a hosting platform. He writes about hosting comparisons, total cost of ownership, web design for Irish businesses, and how to evaluate what you’re actually buying.
More by Eamon Rheinisch →Ready to get your business online?
Describe your business. AI builds your website in 60 seconds.
Build My Website Free →More from the blog
WhatsApp Business Catalogue vs a Website: Where Should Your Orders Live?
WhatsApp Business catalogue or a website? Compare discovery, payment, Meta's rules and Irish consumer law before your busiest week, and see when you need both.
Patreon Alternative for Small Businesses: Paid Memberships on Your Own Website
Looking for a Patreon alternative for paid members? Compare fees, Apple's iPhone commission, VAT and who owns the relationship on your own website.
